An AI devil's advocate that argues the case against your plan
Cabinet's Skeptic joins a discussion when everyone agrees too quickly. It finds the assumption under the plan and the cheapest test that could prove it wrong. It does not vote.
What it does
Finds the shared assumption
When every position rests on one unexamined premise, such as a conversion rate or a launch date, it names it and says whether any of your data supports it.
Makes the other side's best case
It writes the opposing view as its smartest advocate would, using the same facts, before it attacks.
Imagines how the plan could fail
It imagines the plan failed ninety days from now and gives the two or three likeliest causes, with how each would happen.
Proposes a test that can fail
Within about two weeks, at a stated cost, with a number and date. For example: if fewer than 5 of 40 trial accounts turn on a feature by the 26th, the assumption was wrong.
Checks what can be checked
It rechecks the arithmetic, units, and sample sizes, and whether a cited source says what is claimed. It says what it could not check.
Admits when the plan holds
If it tries to break the plan and cannot, it says so, names the weakest point, and the test that would settle it.
Who it works with
The Skeptic has no hires of its own. It works with the other leaders in the weekly meeting.
Use cases
Restaurant
Before a second location
The team loves the idea. The Skeptic points out that all the evidence is from one busy summer, and suggests a one-month pop-up as the test.
Shopify brand
Before a big inventory order
It asks whether the sales spike was the product or a one-time promotion, and proposes a small reorder first.
Software company
Before a price change
It questions the churn assumption and suggests testing the new price on new signups only, with a number to hit.
Team inside a larger company
Before a reorganization
It states the case against the plan, so the decision record shows what was weighed.
Connects to
Stripe
Checks revenue and churn claims
GitHub
Checks claims about what shipped
On its own, and what it asks first
On its own
- Joins a discussion when agreement runs high
- Writes the objection, the pre-mortem, and the test
- Searches the web and reads your records to check a claim
Asks you first
- It does not propose actions or spend anything
- The Chief of Staff decides whether its test becomes an action, and you approve what needs approval
When it shows up
Monday morning
Weekly meeting, when the team agrees too fast
First Monday of each quarter
Quarterly planning, on the quarter's goals
Whenever you ask
A pre-mortem on any plan
Optional
Ideas session, where it tests the pitches, on Team and Pro
Plans
The Skeptic comes with Trial, Team, and Pro. The Owner plan does not include it. In the local business setup it is off until you turn it on.
Questions
What is an AI devil's advocate?
It argues the strongest case against a plan so it gets tested before you commit. Cabinet's version is called the Skeptic. It finds the assumption and proposes a test.
Does the Skeptic vote or block decisions?
No. It does not vote and cannot block. It makes sure the best objection is on the record, with the objection kept in the decision.
Will it object to everything?
It is told not to. One objection with evidence beats five without, and a plan that survives gets a plain statement that it did.
When does it join?
When the team agrees too quickly, and any time you ask it to speak.
Give it your website. Come back to a plan.
Questions: hello@agntwrk.com